Selection criteria
Selection criteria examples from government guides, with notes
Selection criteria identify the requirements you need to evidence. A resume, a combined pitch and separate criteria responses do different jobs: the vacancy information pack decides which to submit. The APSC application guide explains these options. Read the complete responses below, then use our notes to select evidence from your own experience.
By Resumatica Team. Last updated 2026-11-14. The two examples below are quoted exactly as published; our notes are labelled separately.
Jump to
XYZ Bank in the APSC illustration is fictional. Our suggested revisions are writing illustrations, not candidate histories or evidence of hiring outcomes.
Example 1: APSC, a Research Support Officer newsletter
The APSC application guide shows a STAR plan followed by a full paragraph. It does not attach a specific criterion to this newsletter example; do not treat our interpretation as an official question or score.
The STAR plan
Situation—role as Research Support Officer at XYZ Bank.
Task—needed to ensure that managers were kept informed of policies and procedures.
Action or approach—initiated monthly newsletter, which was emailed to each manager. Took responsibility for writing the main articles. This involved obtaining ideas and input from other stakeholders to ensure that the articles reflected managers’ needs in terms of content and language.
Result—led to improved lines of communication between managers and the Research Support Unit. Feedback was consistently excellent. Received divisional achievement award for newsletter quality.
The full paragraph
As Research Support Officer at the XYZ Bank, I needed to ensure that managers were kept informed of policies and procedures. To do this, I initiated a monthly newsletter, which was emailed to each manager. I took responsibility for writing the main articles in each publication. This involved obtaining ideas and input from other stakeholders to ensure that the articles reflected the needs of managers, both in terms of content and language. I received consistently excellent feedback in relation to the newsletter from these internal stakeholders and my own manager. I received a divisional achievement award for the quality of the newsletter. Importantly, this initiative resulted in improved lines of communication between managers and the Research Support Unit.
Source: Australian Public Service Commission, ‘Applying for an APS job: cracking the code’, licensed under CC BY 4.0. See the APSC copyright page. Text copied unchanged, fetched 13 October 2026. This page is not endorsed by the APSC.
Resumatica Team notes
Our reading of how the paragraph follows STAR. This is commentary on the quote above, not part of it.
- SituationAs Research Support Officer at the XYZ Bank,
- TaskI needed to ensure that managers were kept informed of policies and procedures.
- ActionTo do this, I initiated a monthly newsletter, which was emailed to each manager.
- ActionI took responsibility for writing the main articles in each publication.
- ActionThis involved obtaining ideas and input from other stakeholders to ensure that the articles reflected the needs of managers, both in terms of content and language.
- ResultI received consistently excellent feedback in relation to the newsletter from these internal stakeholders and my own manager.
- ResultI received a divisional achievement award for the quality of the newsletter.
- ResultImportantly, this initiative resulted in improved lines of communication between managers and the Research Support Unit.
Length: the paragraph is 118 words.
What makes it work: it opens with the role and the need, uses “I” for the actions, says who gave the feedback, and ends by connecting the result to the people it helped.
What you could add: a measurable result in your own example, such as how many managers received it or how often, if you have the real figure. The quoted result is described in words only.
Adapt the evidence: for a communication question, explain the audience and the language choices you made. For a stakeholder question, explain how you gathered views and resolved differences. The same episode may support either, but only if your own actions answer the actual question. Keep the award and excellent feedback in the source quote; do not copy them into your application unless they happened to you.
Example 2: South Australia Department for Education, literacy support
From the department’s ancillary application guide. It answers the criterion “providing literacy support to students, both individually and in groups”.
Providing literacy support to students, both individual and in groups
I currently assist teaching staff in the conduct of educational programs by completing a range of classroom support activities which contributes to the achievement of educational outcomes of students, specifically in the area of literacy and numeracy. When supporting students (on a 1:1 basis and in small groups) I understand the importance in enhancing their abilities and learning achievements. I do this by developing, selecting and modifying routines and activities to suit individual and/or group requirements. A key element is to widen and expand the learning scope of the students through developing and maintaining their interest. For example, I utilise alphabet cards and require the students to identify and write letters. The students are then asked to draw pictures of objects that start with these letters. I have received positive feedback from teaching staff on my ability to extend the learning of students using these strategies.
© Government of South Australia. Reproduced unaltered, with acknowledgement, from the Department for Education’s Quick reference guide: ancillary job applications. See its copyright notice. Fetched 13 October 2026. This page is not endorsed by the Government of South Australia.
Resumatica Team notes
Our reading of the response, sentence by sentence. This is commentary on the quote above, not part of it.
- SituationI currently assist teaching staff in the conduct of educational programs by completing a range of classroom support activities which contributes to the achievement of educational outcomes of students, specifically in the area of literacy and numeracy.
- TaskWhen supporting students (on a 1:1 basis and in small groups) I understand the importance in enhancing their abilities and learning achievements.
- ActionI do this by developing, selecting and modifying routines and activities to suit individual and/or group requirements.
- ActionA key element is to widen and expand the learning scope of the students through developing and maintaining their interest.
- ActionFor example, I utilise alphabet cards and require the students to identify and write letters. The students are then asked to draw pictures of objects that start with these letters.
- ResultI have received positive feedback from teaching staff on my ability to extend the learning of students using these strategies.
Length: the response (without the heading) is 146 words.
What makes it work: it repeats the criterion as a heading, describes the routine work, then gives one concrete activity (alphabet cards, then drawing objects that start with the letters).
What you could add: when and where the example happened, and a measurable result if you have one. The only outcome given is positive feedback from teaching staff; naming who gave it, or what changed for the students, would make it stronger.
Criterion-to-evidence check: the actual criterion asks for literacy support both individually and in groups. Our annotation below tests those parts, rather than awarding an invented panel score.
- Literacy support: the alphabet-card and drawing activity shows the candidate doing literacy work, rather than just claiming an interest in it.
- Individual and group support: the response names both settings, but does not show how the activity differed between them. In your own response, explain the adjustment you actually made for one learner and for a group.
- Personal action: developing and modifying activities identifies the contribution. Add your reasoning and the teacher’s direction if those are relevant to the role you are applying for.
- Result and its limit: teacher feedback is the only stated outcome. The paragraph does not establish a measured improvement in literacy; do not turn it into a progress percentage or a causal claim.
Resume revision: replace “Helped in class” with “Prepared alphabet-card activities and adapted them for individual and small-group literacy support.” Use this only if it describes your work. In the criteria response, explain the actual adaptation and what you observed; do not add a learner outcome you cannot verify.
Change the focus: for a teamwork criterion, explain how you agreed the activity with teaching staff and shared observations. A literacy response pasted unchanged would leave that collaboration unexplained.
More official guides
These carry their own copyright, so we link to them rather than quote them.
State guidance has its own scope. The WA Public Sector Commission’s program application tips advise checking the advert and attachments and using real examples from work, study or volunteering. Follow the document requirements and limits in your vacancy pack.
Before drafting, record the exact questions, requested documents, limits and closing time from your application pack. STAR is an optional structure in the APSC guide; follow the advert if it asks for a different response. For federal roles, see the APS resume and pitch guide.
- Jobs and Skills WA: Responding to selection criteria
Annotated examples of structure, including multi-part criteria, headings and desirable criteria.
- CFA (Victoria): How to address Key Selection Criteria
Three sample responses to problem solving, computer skills and communication criteria.
- Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council: applying for positions
Two full example responses, for a roads foreman and an administrative assistant role.
- Eurobodalla Shire Council: applying for jobs
Two STAR examples for customer service criteria.
- Australian Public Service Commission: Applying for an APS job
The guide Example 1 comes from, including advice on pitches and statements of claims.
UK Civil Service behaviours
The UK Civil Service publishes definitions of its behaviours and guidance on using the STAR method, under the Open Government Licence. We did not find an official sample behaviour statement, so we do not show one here.
Sources reviewed November 2026.
Draft your own responses
Plan your own evidence for free with no AI. After signup, the helper can draft from your resume and notes; check every claim before submitting.